Site Logo

Girl scout cookies ranked

Site Logo

Right now, swarms of future boss-ladies-in-training are putting on their patch-covered vests to sell Girl Scout Cookies wherever they can particularly outside grocery stores , presenting you with a big choice to make: Which sweet treat do you go for? Collectively, Girl Scouts sell more than million boxes of cookies a year, and everyone has a favorite. But, which Girl Scout cookie really does taste the best? We decided to find out by testing every single one. Each baker may have a slightly different recipe for each cookie and may also call their products different names hence, Caramel deLites or Samoas. The cookies you buy depend on what baker your local troop sources its cookies from you can find this information right on the package near the nutrition label.

SEE VIDEO BY TOPIC: Pastry Chef Reviews Girl Scout Cookies

SEE VIDEO BY TOPIC: British People Trying Girl Scout Cookies: ABC Vs Little Brownie Bakers - This With Them

Girl Scout Cookie Program®

Site Logo

There's no debating how amazing Girl Scout Cookies are. They're absolutely delicious, and we're supporting a good cause by buying them, right? That's all the justification we need. The only real question is: which cookie is the best? Girl Scouts sell 16 different types of cookie, and everyone has a favorite and an argument to explain why it's the best. And that got me thinking Breaking down the bakers.

There are two bakeries that make Girl Scout Cookies. New Jersey is one of the rare states that gets supplied by both. Why does this matter? Both bakeries make six of the same cookies with slight differences, including names. The bakeries have several of their own unique cookies as well.

Savannah Smiles. You feel that? Way too sweet, way too tart. Courtesy of Little Brownie Bakers. S'Mores Little Brownie Bakers. The graham cookie is gritty and somewhat cloying, the chocolate is a little off.

The marshmallow is probably better than the ABC version, but the cookie still gave me a bad aftertaste that I struggled to shake. Not bad for a gluten-free cookie, but nothing to write home about. Nice buttery flavor, but the texture is dry and not very pleasant. The toffee bits could be crunchier, and would add to overall mouth-feel yes, we are talking Girl Scout cookie mouth-feel.

Like fine wine. Get over it. It tastes good. Not really. The chocolate is a little off, it tastes almost minty. Peanut Butter Sandwiches. Basically a peanut butter Oreo. If not, skip to the next cookie. I had never even heard of these cookies, and I was pleasantly surprised. Pretty comparable to the peanut butter patties. Maybe a little thinner, but similar crunch.

Peanut Butter Patties. Crunchier than I remember, but definitely tasty. The chocolate is better than most of the chocolate in these cookies and the peanut butter is flavorful but not overpowering. Not wild about the texture. The icing is about the same, but the texture of the cookie is just so much nicer and makes for a way more enjoyable eating experience. These cookies are incredibly overlooked because they don't look fancy or crazy. They just taste good. A nice crunch, pleasant vanilla flavoring.

Excellent in milk. The vanilla flavoring is a richer as well. The most overlooked Girl Scout Cookie, in my humble opinion. Caramel deLites. I love this cookie. Coconut, caramel and chocolate is a ridiculous combination that comes together beautifully to make this the most unique Girl Scout concoction. The texture isn't quite as good as the Little Brownie version, which is really the only thing wrong with it.

Thin Mints Little Brownie Bakers. These are delicious. Maybe some would prefer that, but I want as much mint in my Thin Mint as possible. Still, there's a reason they're this high. They're really good. I can already hear the groans. How are Thin Mints not No. Yes, they may be the most popular cookie, but they're not the best. They're minty, chocolately and delicious. And you can get something similar all year — chocolate mint, or "grasshopper" cookies have become immensely popular.

Love Thin Mints, they're just not No. The most delicious and most unique cookie Girl Scouts have to offer. Whoever thought to combine coconut, caramel and chocolate on a cookie deserves a Nobel Prize. In what field? Who cares, eat a Samoa. They're amazing. Love the texture, love the flavor. Love everything. Jeremy Schneider may be reached at jschneider njadvancemedia. Find NJ. All rights reserved About Us. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local.

Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. Ad Choices. Skip to Main Content. Subscriptions NJ. News Local News N. Contribute to NJ. More on NJ. Mobile iPhone, Android apps.

Girl Scout Cookies ranked from worst to first

Sure, these organizations build character and confidence in young woman nationwide, but the average Joe knows that they build pantries full of delicious treats. Girl Scout cookies have a storied history with over 50 cookies previously and presently available. So we took some of the most popular, most confounding, and most modern cookies and matched them up against one another. Golden Yangles? But it was still, you know, a cookie, and not a superfood.

Eating Girl Scout Cookies has become a yummy annual tradition for Americans from sea to shining sea. You simply pick your favorite variety of Girl Scout Cookies and once the box is in your hands, you gleefully stuff your face.

Find cookies, learn when cookie season starts in your community, and locate cookie sale booths by simply entering your zip code in the Find Cookies! You can also call or email your local Girl Scout council. Council staff or volunteers can help you find a cookie booth near you. Councils conduct their cookie season for about a six- to eight-week period per year, most between January and April, but some as early as September.

The best and worst Girl Scout Cookies, ranked

Girl Scout cookie season is pretty much its own holiday. Once the green table-clothed tables hit supermarkets and big box stores nationwide, it can turn into an all-out battle for the last box of Samoas, er, Caramel DeLites. Whatever your region of the country calls them, the culty cookies are so popular that the organization created online ordering, because even though making your own can be fun it's just not the same. And while we figured out which cookies are best for your sign, everyone knows there is a hierarchy. Here is the objective ranking of the worst Girl Scout cookie These are way too healthy to be enjoyed in mass consumption like Girl Scout cookies should and deserve to be. You're better off buying a pricey granola bar and calling it a day. Sorry not sorry.

The Best Girl Scout Cookies Ever, Ranking

These things are the communion wafers of the cookie world. It's not like they're BAD — they're still cookies , after all — but they're just very plain. The Girl Scouts have given you so many incredible options to choose from. I shudder to think about the kind of person who opts for these.

It's Girl Scout Cookie season, and our nation's best and brightest young ladies are out and about selling their baked goods to any American looking to get a merit badge in shamelessly housing a whole box of Thin Mints or who just bought a truckload of keef. It's also the time of year when grown-ups get into heated debates about which cookie is the best.

You can tell a lot about a person by their preference for… Girl Scout Cookies. When it comes to character-defining foods, these sweet treats peddled by entrepreneurial girls pretty much top the list. In matters pertaining to Girl Scout Cookies , everyone comes out a winner especially if your research compels you to sample all the flavors. Besides, I think we both know that not all Girl Scout Cookies are created equal.

All 16 Girl Scout Cookies, ranked worst to best

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience while browsing it. By clicking 'Got It' you're accepting these terms. However, that doesn't mean we can't have a few treats once in a while, nor does it mean our diet is "unhealthy" when we do.


There's no debating how amazing Girl Scout Cookies are. They're absolutely delicious, and we're supporting a good cause by buying them, right? That's all the justification we need. The only real question is: which cookie is the best? Girl Scouts sell 16 different types of cookie, and everyone has a favorite and an argument to explain why it's the best. And that got me thinking

A Definitive Ranking of Every Girl Scout Cookie

No need to check the forecast. The only one that matters right now is that Girl Scout Cookie Season is upon us. Are you TeamSamoa or a die-hard Thin Mint stan? Does peanut butter trump lemon? Your city or ZIP code. News Break App. Kimorra Ross Mae Velez Barrovecchio. Struggling Minnesota restaurants are selling what's in their pantries — and home cooks benefit.

Every Girl Scout Cookie, Ranked. By Lee Breslouer. Published on 3/1/ at PM. Assorted girl scout cookies on colorful background. Lee Breslouer &.

I had no idea how many people would reply with very incorrect answers. But there were a lot of you, and I respect you all for being out and proud about your extremely wrong opinions. It takes a ton of courage to not only have a bad idea but to share it with so many people. So I gathered my coworkers together for a tasting of all the Girl Scout Cookies or at least all the ones available in Oklahoma City and had them rank each one and give notes on why.

We Tried Every Girl Scout Cookie—This One Is the Best

Every year, after the holidays die down and the decorations are put away, something beautiful happens that brings so many people, myself included, endless joy. And that, my friends, is Girl Scout Cookie season. Girl Scout Cookies are typically sold between January and April, so it's officially time to spend more than a few paychecks on those delicious little cookies it's fine since the cookie proceeds go to a good cause.






Comments: 5
  1. Akilrajas

    I am assured, what is it — a false way.

  2. Bagore

    Willingly I accept. The theme is interesting, I will take part in discussion. I know, that together we can come to a right answer.

  3. Shamuro

    I apologise, but, in my opinion, you are mistaken. Let's discuss it. Write to me in PM, we will talk.

  4. Sazilkree

    Bravo, this excellent phrase is necessary just by the way

  5. Ketaur

    Yes you are talented

Thanks! Your comment will appear after verification.
Add a comment

© 2020 Online - Advisor on specific issues.